Geek Revolt

Tomb Raider Review: Lara’s Deception

0fcfe416a700cdd937561ad0964a0299

Let’s get this out of the way. Don’t read this review if you’re expecting impossible jumps, crazy puzzles, and short shorts. This reboot isn’t for you my dear friend. Because this is a Tomb Raider game in name only. So run — run as fast as you can in the opposite direction. Okay, now that they’re gone let’s get down to business.

The StoryTomb Raider explores the intense and gritty origin story of Lara Croft and her ascent from a young woman to a hardened survivor. Armed only with raw instincts and the ability to push beyond the limits of human endurance, Lara must fight to unravel the dark history of a forgotten island to escape its relentless hold.

[toggle_box title=”Game Details” width=”Width of toggle box”]

Title: Tomb Raider
Genre: Third Person Shooter
Developer: Crystal Dynamics
Platforms: Playstation 3
Price: $49.99 – $59.99
ESRB: Mature
Release Date: March 5, 2013[/toggle_box]

0651c64af8bc077048dfead3dcc70aa9

PRAISE:

  • Quite the Looker – The art direction is stellar and graphically this gives most modern games a run for their money. Now keep in mind that I played the PC version. But I’ve seen the console ones in action and in my opinion they look great too.
  • An Interesting Tale – The story borrows heavily from LOST, but it’s an interesting enough tale. Everyone loves a mysterious Island, right? And it’s smoke monster free!
  • Shoot – The shooting feels just as good as it does in any other third person shooter. Aiming is easy and you’ll be pulling off headshots in no time. Wait – I can’t believe we’re talking about headshots in a Tomb Raider game. It’s kind of weird, but you quickly get over it.
  • Loot – You gain salvage and weapon parts by looting dead enemies, killing animals, and opening crates. This quickly becomes addictive because it feeds into gamers’ basic desire to collect tons of useless junk.
  • Upgrade, Upgrade, Upgrade – Okay, salvage isn’t useless. It’s used to upgrade your gear. I put most of my points into the bow because I wanted to reenact the Hunger Games. The system isn’t extremely deep, but it adds a sense of progression. You can also upgrade Lara’s abilities. Want to use your axe as a mêlée weapon? Go for it!
  • Katniss Would Be Proud – Lara loves her bow and it’s easily the best weapon in the game. Once fully upgraded it becomes a force to be reckoned with. There’s nothing more satisfying than pulling off a headshot with a fire arrow.
  • Smart Cover – You won’t find a cover button here. Lara automatically goes into cover when you run up to something. Gone are the days of getting shot because you didn’t press circle fast enough. Every third person shooter needs to adopt a similar system.
  • Lara the Explorer – Tomb Raider doesn’t have an open world, but it’s far from linear. It opens up more as you progress and you can use the base camps to revisit old areas. Some areas are inaccessible at first, but you can go back and explore them once you’ve upgraded your equipment.

cc2f0ceb5e01752ecd2dc20065457850

  • #Reborn – Camilla Luddington delivers a believable performance as a young Lara Croft. Camilla’s task wasn’t an easy one. She had to honor Lara’s legacy while displaying a certain level of vulnerability. She does this and more with ease.
  • A Tight Squeeze – The camera always moved to the perfect position. When Lara enters a tight space it zooms in and makes things feel tenser. Prepare to freak out a little if you’re claustrophobic.
  • Audio Logs – Reading someone’s diary is wrong, but that doesn’t stop Lara from reading everything she gets her bloody little hands on. These diaries provide insight into the minds of your crewmates and the island’s inhabitants. Oh and they’re fully voiced.
  • Darkly Dreaming – I won’t give anything away, but this game can be really dark at times. Some sections had a survivor horror feel to them.
  • Island Life – Yamatai is filled with wild animals to hunt, secrets, treasure, beautiful vistas, and bloodthirsty savages. It’s the real star of this adventure.
  • The Little Things – Lara reacts to her surroundings. When she’s in a tight spot she’ll gently rub her hands against a nearby wall and when an enemy is close she automatically starts to slowdown and crouch. She also looks around frantically when she hears something terrifying in the distance. Lara’s believable interactions with her environments make Tomb Raider one deeply immersive experience.
  • PC Options – I played the PC version and it’s a great port. There’s a wide range of options and it looks good even on normal settings. It also has hair physics and a benchmarking tool. I couldn’t crank the settings up on my iMac, but I’ve seen videos of the game on ultra and it looks wonderful. But like I said – the game looks great on normal settings too.
  • PC Options II - My iMac has an AMD Radeon HD 6770M and I could play the game on normal settings at 720p. I averaged 43 frames per second on these settings. This isn’t bad for a computer that isn’t really made for gaming.
  • Uncharted? – When Tomb Raider was first shown off everyone said, “It looks like an Uncharted clone!” Now, at first it does feel like Uncharted with a female lead. But as you progress you soon realize that this isn’t a carbon copy of Uncharted. Actually, at times it feels more like Batman Arkham City thanks to the hub areas and “Survivor Instinct”. The marketing team did this reboot a disservice by just focusing on the action and set pieces. There’s more to the game. Naughty Dog could learn a thing or two from Tomb Raider. Because this game easily tops Uncharted 3. The subtitle for this review isn’t Lara’s Deception because I think this is an Uncharted clone. It’s because I feel like most of Tomb Raider‘s promotional materials deceived the hell out of us. The game is more interesting than it originally appears.

5b6511049d99605c7442cc2ee3e82bd1

AWKWARD SILENCE:

  • Magnetic Ledges – The platforming is automatic. Just jump in the right direction and Lara will magically fly towards the ledge. This will disappoint long time fans and anyone looking for a challenging platformer.
  • Press ‘Y’ or Die! – The QTEs are kind of annoying. Prepare to die often until you get the timing right. I wish developers would abolish QTEs. They add nothing to a game. There are tons in the beginning, but they drop off by the end of Lara’s adventure.
  • Hunting is Shallow – You don’t have to hunt to survive. You just kill animals for extra salvage.
  • Wave After Wave – Really? Another wave of enemies? I just killed hundreds of your brothers – call it a day. Sigh, okay, here’s an arrow to the… face. Jokes aside – the endless waves of enemies can become tedious.
  • You Call That a Puzzle? – The puzzles are a little on the easy side. A few of the optional tombs are confusing at first, but once you figured out what to do you can solve them in a matter of minutes.
  • So So Multiplayer – The multiplayer isn’t bad, but it’s nothing to get excited about. Serviceable is the best way to describe it. I could go into more detail, but if you’ve ever played a third person shooter online then you already know what to expect.

4dc77ca19c6a2cf284af5523b235db9c

WELL-DESERVED CRITICISMS:

  • Walking ClichésTomb Raider’s cast of characters includes a tough black woman, generic geek, lovable big guy, supportive best friend, mad scientist, wise old man, and a few other stereotypical character archetypes. These walking clichés get some backstory in the form of audio logs, but they never become truly interesting.

049a301b2d97168c7a1571ec1d6187d0

CONCLUSION:

Crystal Dynamics crafted one of the best third person shooters of this generation, but it’s also one of the most derivative games ever created. It shamelessly wears its influences on its sleeve (every popular game from the past five years). This doesn’t take much away from the game, though. It’s still one hell of a ride and a must buy for fans of the genre.

[box_light]We believe that the score is the least important part of a review. It’s tough trying to assign a numerical value to an experience. Is there really a difference between a 7.5 and an 8? Gamers place too much importance on arbitrary numbers. This is why our scores are hidden by default. Only look at them if you absolutely need a number between 1-10 to see if a game is worth your time. You can read our review guidelines here.[/box_light]

[toggle_box title=”Scorecard” width=”Width of toggle box”]

Gameplay: 9
Story: 8
Graphics: 9.5
Sound: 9.5
Replay Value: 8
Overall: 9

Amazing – This is a must have, you’ll see this game on top ten lists at the end of the year.[/toggle_box]

I'm DeShaun Zollicoffer, and I approve this message/bio. "26-years-old, Proud Northeast Ohioan, a Gamer Without Loyalties, an Equal Opportunity Offender, Apple Evangelist, Apple Hater, Music Lover, Anime Junkie, Little Monster, Frequent Flyer, Dexter Fanatic, Title Case Addict, and Geek Revolt's Founder and Editorial Director."
  • XavierLeromeLangham

    oh man i have this for pc i can’t wait to sit down and play it

    • http://www.geekrevolt.com/ DeShaun Zollicoffer

      Nice, I hope you enjoy it as much as I did.

      • XavierLeromeLangham

        so i got to sit down and play it for the pc LOVED it so far i only have two problems QTE and what’s up with you not being able to swim in the water

        • robtion

          Swimming would be nice. Hopefully in the sequel.

  • http://geekrevolt.com/author/fallguysoldier/ Edgar Ocampo

    Phew! Man I’m relieved this game didn’t turn out as bad as I feared. Thanks for the review, I’ll be sure to pick this game up. My only question now is for which platform…

    • http://www.geekrevolt.com/ DeShaun Zollicoffer

      PC if you have a system that can run it. Although, the console versions are good too.

      • http://geekrevolt.com/author/fallguysoldier/ Edgar Ocampo

        Yeah, I figured the PC would look and run the best. It’s just more of a question for continuity’s sake… I originally planned on getting the Tomb Raider trilogy pack on the PS3 and Guardian of Light from the PSN, so it would make sense to get this new Tomb Raider game for the PS3 as well. But then again, I’ve still yet to buy them all, so… I dunno… maybe I should just give Steam more of my money and play on the PC instead lol.

        • http://www.geekrevolt.com/ DeShaun Zollicoffer

          Giving more money to Steam is never a bad idea. Gabe needs another billion in the bank lol :)

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Daniel-Hill/577748173 Daniel Hill

    I wouldn’t say this is Tomb Raider in name only, it still maintains the mysterious feeling of past entries in the series. The game is just far less dry now. It is defined by more than its mechanics and its scenery.

  • robtion

    Great game and another excellent review. Agree with everything except I really don’t mind qte’s. Don’t really get peoples issue with them.